menu

The ACELG guest lecture of Tuesday 27th March, “Europe in Need of a New Deal. On Federalism, Free Market and the Right to Strike ” was held by Federico Fabbrini, currently PhD candidate at the European University Institute (Florence) and soon to begin a new phase in his career with a position as Assistant Professor at Tilburg University.

Federico’s PhD thesis “Fundamental Rights in Europe: Challenges and Transformations of a Multilevel System in Comparative Perspective” tries to tackle the impact of Europe’s multi-level structure on fundamental rights by doing “case studies” on rights from different “generations”. For the generation of social rights, the chosen domain is that of the right to strike, which provides a good example of differences among member states and carries great symbolical value for many European systems. The paper presented in the lecture draws a parallel between the experience of growing supranational influence in the regulation of strike in the EU and the “federalisation” of strike regulation in the US.

As to the first part, Federico’s inquiry dives into national systems’ protection of the right to strike and into the parallel “system” originating from case law of the CJEU on the relationship between strike and the exercise of fundamental freedoms, identified with the notable- and, for some, notorious- Viking and Laval decisions. The result of this investigation, which takes many member states into account, is that European countries’ laws on strike vary within a very broad spectrum, where some countries stand out for their very high level of protection (such as Italy and, above all, France), while on the other extreme the UK maintains the singularity of a fundamental non-recognition of strike as a full-fledged right but as an exemption from liability arising from collective action. Against this background, the author-lecturer argues, the Court of Justices seems to be positioned around the middle of the spectrum. The doctrine emerging from the court’s decisions results in a judgment of proportionality of the undertaken action, centred on the objectives pursued and the availability of less disruptive alternatives. This approach, accordingly, should not be seen as an original result of the Court’s creativity: it rather resembles the model in place in Germany, which the author had placed around the midway of a virtual “France-England” axis. In borrowing this standard, however, the Court forces a large number of Member States to enforce, in cases with a cross-border element, a level of protection which is considerably lower than the one in place for purely internal cases, generating tensions within different levels of regulation and challenges for the concerned national regulators. What does this have to do with the United States? Although aware of the limits of an EU-US comparison for normative intents, the author claims that this comparison can serve as a “mirror” in which the EU can see reflected some if its current struggles. In examining Northern American legal developments during the New Deal and beyond, Federico emphasises the importance of establishing a wide common standard for the protection of the right to strike. According to his reconstruction, a struggle between national laws and interstate commerce (and the subsequent judicial review in the hands of the Federal Supreme Court) was also in place in the United States at the beginning of the 20th century and culminated in the adoption of the National Labour Relation Act (NLRA) of 1937, which contained (among others) a federal regulation of strike and was issued under the so-called “commerce clause”.

Back on the Continent, it might be wishful thinking to hope for a revirement in the Court of Justice’s case-law. Whereas, with the recent decisions in Demir (2008) and Enerji (2009), important steps have been done in the parallel jurisdiction of the European Court of Human Rights towards a full recognition of the right to strike as a fundamental right, it is doubtful that the CJEU will alter its position in light of these judgments- which were rendered against Turkey, where strikes are basically forbidden, and address a purely “vertical” relationship instead of “horizontal” conflicts. What then? The author looks with relative favour at the recently presented proposal for a EU regulation “on the exercise of the right to take collective action within the context of the freedom of establishment and the freedom to provide services”, which, while basically codifying the standard elaborated by the Court has the merit of bringing the topic in the legislative arena. The limits associated to the explicit exclusion, in Article 153(2) TFEU, of a Union competence to regulate strike seem to be de facto, if not de jure, overcome by the Court’s activism in the field. The uncertain legality of a similar act, however, seems likely to have caused the Commission’s decision to choose Article 352 as a legal basis for the proposal, instead of the general competence under Article 114 TFEU. Since the former requires unanimity, it would give some guarantee that, if adopted, the Regulation would not be later challenged before the CJEU. The author, however, would favour adoption under the internal market competence of Article 114.

In spite of its self-qualification as a purely constitutional law analysis, the seminar drew the attention of various researchers from other disciplines, eager to engage in further discussion. The parallel with the US was the object of some debate between Federico and Professor Jonathan Zeitlin (from the Faculty of Political Science, UvA), who questioned the similarity between the struggles occurring on the two sides of the Atlantic and the emphasis placed on the NLRA in isolation from other relevant legislation. Chantal Mak (CSECL) wondered whether the level of protection enforced by the Court represents a standard or- which is the case according to the lecturer- a ceiling below which member states are free to remain. Federico also defended some of his choices and preferences against issues raised with regard to the representative value of the right to strike within a fundamental rights research and the hardly surmountable perplexity of the small CSECL troop (and especially of his fellow former EUI- student Marija Bartl) towards a regulation of strike under the vessel of economic freedoms and away from more intense political discussion. Under the stimulus of Professor Deidre Curtin, finally, Federico provided the audience further insight in his methodology and the research design that stirred him during his PhD journey. The latter will find its conclusion on the 4th of June, with the defence of Federico’s thesis- that many of us will now be very curious to read.