Expert Policymaking in times of Democratic Crisis
Highlights and reflections from the RED-SPINEL Seminar on “The Place of Expertise in EU Policymaking”
PhD researchers, Irthe de Jong and Sofie Fleerackers, share their thoughts on the seminar held earlier this year on 'The Place of Expertise in EU Policymaking'. The seminar was led by Professor Chiara Armeni and Professor Christina Eckes, and took place as part of the RED SPINEL project.

By Irthe de Jong (RED-SPINEL) and Sofie Fleerackers (GEM-DIAMOND)
Uniting legal scholars from academic partners in RED SPINEL – a Horizon Europe-funded project – as well as beyond, the University of Amsterdam Centre for European Law and Governance organized a Seminar in March 2023 to tackle the place of expertise in EU policymaking, and ultimately the EU as a democracy. This blog post first summarizes the seminar, which featured one keynote, two-panel sessions, and a concluding round-table discussion. Secondly, the post shares some of our reflections as participants in the seminar.
The European Union is increasingly apt at infusing expertise into its governance framework. We can recognize the EU’s reliance on expert knowledge in policy actions ranging from climate change and environmental degradation to migration, and the rise of new technologies. However, such use of expertise does not come without its challenges, especially in times of democratic crisis. While reliance on expert knowledge increases rationality and scientism in policymaking, and can even serve to depoliticize complex issues, a too strong reliance on legal expertise may also set the EU up to evade the difficult normative questions that inevitably come up when just policies need to be designed. Even more so, the opaque use of (legal) expertise has given rise to accusations of technocracy within the EU and has amounted to a perceived disconnect between the EU’s policies and the public. Ensuring visibility to the public into how legal questions are handled in EU policymaking is a precondition of the rule of law, and a degree of transparency that seems to be lacking today. The question arises how the EU can build on expert knowledge for its problem-solving value without forsaking democratic legitimacy.