What is the EMFA?

Platformisation, combined with geopolitical challenges such as disinformation, ideological hybrid warfare, the COVID-19 crisis and the backsliding of the rule of law has challenged the economic viability and democratic function of the media over the past two decades. To address these challenges, the European Commission, exercising its competence to regulate the internal market for media services, adopted a proposal for a European Media Freedom Act (‘Proposal’) in September 2022.

What will it do?

With the Proposal, the Commission takes a long awaited supranational action to address growing economic and fundamental rights concerns in the media sector including some Member States’ capture and regulatory abuses in the control of the media. The Proposal outlines a set of new rules to promote media pluralism and independence across the EU with the aim to increase the transparency, independence and accountability of actions affecting European media markets. Besides important substantive provisions, the Proposal contains various enforcement mechanisms concerning the role of national regulatory authorities, the newly established European Board for Media Services (Board) and the Commission.

Sounds good! So, what’s the issue?

The proposed tools in their current form are weak and cautious, aiming at friendly cooperation rather than effective and credible enforcement structured. In fact, it is highly questionable whether these mechanisms are capable of improving the already available enforcement mechanisms in EU law. Especially in situations of systemic non-compliance by national regulatory authorities or their Member States, they are predestined to fail. As media pluralism reveals a complex puzzle in the EU’s legal order, legal solutions are certainly not straightforward. While, media pluralism features among the most important values of the EU, the Union lacks an explicit competence to regulate the media and media as a field of EU policy is absent from the Treaties.

Against this background, Kati Cseres (ACELG), together with Judit Bayer (University of Munster, Budapest Business School) have advised Members of the European Parliament in preparing their amendments for the EMFA Proposal. By drawing on their expertise in media law and EU competition law they offered concrete tools and examples to improve the currently drafted enforcement mechanismms in the EMFA Proposal. You can read a summary of their recommendations concerning the enforcement of the EMFA in a Verfassungsblog. They provided concrete steps on how to improve enforcement of media law and policy in the EU in general, while remaining within the boundaries of the competences as established by the EU Treaties.