Event details from: Challenging the Validity of EU Acts: International Law as a Sword or a Shield?

Date
9 November 2020
Time
15:30 – 17:00

Abstract

Issues of public international law make their way before the EU Court of Justice (CJEU) in a variety of ways. In recent years, litigants have sought to challenge the validity of EU acts on the grounds that the act violates the EU’s obligation, set out in Article 3(5) TEU, to “contribute […] to the strict observance and the development of international law”. The CJEU has interpreted this provision to mean that when the EU adopts an act, it must observe international law binding on the Union, including customary international law. Yet Article 3(5) TEU has never been successfully used to challenge the internal validity of an EU act. One may imagine that Article 3(5) TEU provides an opportunity for litigants to ensure the Union respects international law in fields of human rights, refugee law, or international humanitarian law. Yet in practice, this provision has also been used by businesses and industry organizations to challenge the validity of EU legislation that seeks to address issues such as climate change or maritime pollution.

This paper examines the instances where international law has been used to assess the validity of EU acts before the CJEU, with a focus on recent case law involving Article 3(5) TEU. It examines a number of EU law issues faced by the Court – who is capable of challenging EU acts; which EU acts are capable of being challenged; on what grounds may they be challenged; the type and intensity of review that the Court carries out; and the consequences that would flow, at the EU and international law plane, from a finding of invalidity. It shows how litigants have been much more successful challenging EU acts on ‘EU law ground’, rather than by invoking public international law arguments. It shows how, while the Court is open to interpreting and applying international law in its reasoning, it is often employed as a shield to support EU acts, and not as a sword to strike them down.

Speaker

Dr Jed Odermatt is a Lecturer at the City Law School, University of London and a member of the Institute for the Study of European Law (ISEL) and International Law and Affairs Group (ILAG).

He was previously a post-doctoral researcher at the Centre of Excellence for International Courts (iCourts) at the University of Copenhagen, a Max Weber Fellow at the European University Institute (EUI), Florence, and a Research Fellow at the Leuven Centre for Global Governance Studies, University of Leuven. He was a Visiting Scholar at the Lauterpacht Centre for International Law, University of Cambridge, and a Junior Researcher at the TMC Asser Institute, Centre for International and European Law, The Hague. Dr Odermatt undertook an internship at the Trial Chamber of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY).

Dr Odermatt has a PhD in Law from the University of Leuven (Belgium), a degree in Law from Flinders University (Australia) and an LL.M. in International and European Public Law from Tilburg University (the Netherlands). He was an Assistant Editor of the European Journal of International Law (EJIL) and is currently an editor and regular contributor to the Oxford Reports on International Law in EU Courts. Dr Odermatt is also an active member of the European Society of International Law Interest Group on 'The EU as a Global Actor'.